It has become something of a tradition around our house to set aside the Saturday night of the annual White House Correspondents Dinner and hunker down and watch the proceedings on CSPAN. There have been years when the featured comedian and the sitting president put on a very funny show. Even years when the program was merely 'ok' it was worth the time.
Last night the special guest was Stephen Colbert of Comedy Central's Colbert Report and recently we have become fans of his, either staying up later than usual to watch his program or catching the rerun the following evening at 7:30. So, we had high hopes for his appearance at the big media dinner. However, we were very disappointed. He was much too cruel, some media reports are describing his tone as "cutting", but it was certainly much too harsh for this kind of event where the norm is to poke fun at the president and current affairs in, if not an affectionate way, then in something of a lighthearted way.
Some reviewers believe as Ann Althouse wrote, that he had to stay in keeping with his character on the Report or risk losing his fan base. I disagree because the Colbert personna on Comedy Central affects an almost politically androgenous manner. Republicans like him because although he is being satirical, the satire leaves room for viewers who support President Bush to find something to like. That was lost last night. The video bit with Colbert trying frantically to escape aged reporter Helen Thomas was the one funny part, but it came too late to save Stephen Colbert. The audience, made up of movie stars and famous athletes and major news people were mostly silent during his time at the podium which says a lot about how he did.
We will probably continue to watch the Colbert Report, but not quite as often and not with the same affection for the man.
On the other hand, President Bush's time at the podium featured a Bush impersonator, Steve Bridges, who stood along side the president and played the part of his alter ego, saying things you just know Bush would like to say if he thought he could. Excellently done and brilliant comedy. The audience laughed hard throughout. Which tells you something.
Joe Gandelman of the Moderate Voice has a good roundup of opinion on last night's dinner.