Students have moaned about teachers forever, mostly out of earshot of the teacher. Teachers know this, teachers complain about students too. Mostly out of earshot of the students.
So this story from Chicago suburban Oak Forest is interesting. Should a student be suspended for criticizing a teacher on a Facebook page?
Sophomore Justin Bird was given a 5 day suspension after creating a Facebook page about the teacher. The suspension will be removed from his permanent record:
"if the student completes a program that deals with anger management
and making better choices, he can have three of the five suspension
days removed from his disciplinary record.
An outside consultant is being brought in to work with the student,
but the family has to pay $25 for the four 1 1 / 2 -hour sessions."
Justin did not use school time or school computers to do the Facebook page.
But wait, there's more, this time about the teacher:
"...during parent-teacher conferences in November the
teacher admitted to trying to "get a rise" out of Justin on several
occasions but would stop. However, it began again, she said, and during
one encounter the teacher called Justin "stupid" in front of his
classmates."
Have other school districts created policies similar to this? Is it fair? Should not the teacher also have received some sort of reprimand? Or should this just have been ignored?